Friday, December 25, 2009

Moderate Islam?

What does the moderate in "moderate Islam" refer to.

According to Merrriam-Webster, the different meanings of moderate, used as an adjective, are:

1 a : avoiding extremes of behavior or expression : observing reasonable limits b : calm, temperate
2 a : tending toward the mean or average amount or dimension b : having average or less than average quality : mediocre
3 : professing or characterized by political or social beliefs that are not extreme
4 : limited in scope or effect
5 : not expensive : reasonable or low in price
6 of a color : of medium lightness and medium chroma

Source: http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/moderate

I think the reference is to meanings labeled 1a and 3 respectively. The view assumes that Western civilization is the standard civilization, the status quo, and Islam must conform to it. Despite being a Westerner in thought, I find this assumption disgusting. In sheer number of adherents, Islam may have more adherents than Western civilization, which I have used to refer to a secular, techno-scientific society. Many Americans won't be adherents of the above-mentioned "Western civilization", especially the Evangelist creationists. Use of technology, without accepting science, cannot be a differentiating factor for "moderate Islam" as most "radical Islamicists" are avid users of technology.

2 comments:

Mihir jha said...

hey sanket,
i came across your blog in my quest to search writers for my upcoming online magazine to be called "reader's Quotient" which is different from rest any other magazine in the sense that it is totally devoted for the cause of the society.....i wanted to share the concept with u and take ur feedback on the same....and in case u like u can come along with us....please let us know....i can be contacted at mihirjha@readersquotient.com

Keep posting :) !!!

Regds/Mihir

Unknown said...

Hi Sanket,

Read your comment on the book Difficulty of Being Good on Gurcharan Das's blog and got interested in reading more of your blogs.

Would like to have your comments on review of the book on my blog:
http://babelz-openletter.blogspot.com/

I feel there is a need to analyse and understand the characters of Mahabharat in detail with the 'original' perspective.

Regards
Babel